Holiday Cookie Walk


Thank you to all the Cookie Elves, Santa’s Helpers and the many wonderful patrons who supported our Holiday Cookie Walk this year!  We had a fabulous selection of cookies, candies, and sweet bread this year with just enough for everyone!

Sherry Goldman donated a beautiful hand made wall hanging she made that was won by Jim Merritt. He was very surprised and thrilled.

We are looking forward to next year and are looking at a date.  If you would like to join this jolly band of volunteers, we would love to have you!  Email me at

December 2019

10 am until gone

Penn Yan Presbyterian Church

They sell out quickly, so come early!

Sign Up To Bake – Sign up here

Bakers: What we’re looking for:

  • 6 dozen of your very best, fanciest, most Martha Stewart-esqe Holiday cookies
  • (which is about two batches of cookie)
  • We need all of your cookies to be the same type/variety (not an assortment)
  • Old-fashioned favorites – cutouts, chocolate crinkles, peanut butter blossoms, spritz, molasses…
  • Your most-requested recipe, perhaps? thumbprints, pecan tassies, coconut macaroons…
  • Sophisticated or Whimsical – gingerbread, rum balls, brandy snaps, walnut cookies, springerle…
  • Traditional, Ethnic, or Hard-To-Find – Russian tea cakes, rugelach, baklava, linzer cookies…
  • They don’t have to be Christmas cookies… any Winter Holiday will do!

We have LOTS of ideas and LOTS of really great recipes, so let us know if you need either.

If you’d rather just make dough, please do so! And we’ll make sure the cookies are baked and finished to completion!

If you’d rather not bake, but just want to decorate, you’re more than welcome! Let us know!

Contact: Maureen Wise (315) 536-1690  or email